Skip to content
conftrace_
2026 ICML ICML 2026

On the Interplay of Pre-Training, Mid-Training, and RL on Reasoning Language Models

Recent reinforcement learning (RL) techniques have yielded impressive reasoning improvements in language models, yet it remains unclear whether RL truly extends a model’s reasoning ability beyond pre-training. A central challenge is the lack of control in modern training pipelines, where opaque pre-training data, underexplored mid-training, and complex RL interactions obscure causal effects. To resolve this ambiguity, we develop a controlled experimental framework that isolates the causal contributions of pre-training, mid-training, and RL-based post-training. Our approach employs synthetic reasoning tasks with explicit atomic operations, parseable step-by-step reasoning traces, and systematic manipulation of training distributions. We evaluate along: extrapolative generalization to more complex compositions and contextual generalization across surface contexts. Using this framework, we reconcile competing views on RL’s effectiveness: 1) RL produces true capability gains (pass@128) only when pre-training leaves sufficient headroom and RL data target the model’s edge of competence, tasks that are difficult but not yet out of reach. 2) Contextual generalization requires minimal yet sufficient pre-training exposure, after which RL reliably transfers. 3) Mid-training significantly enhances performance under fixed compute compared with RL alone, demonstrating its central but underexplored role. 4) Process-level rewards reduce reward hacking and improve reasoning fidelity. Together, these results clarify the interplay between pre-training, mid-training, and RL, offering a foundation for improving reasoning language models training strategies. Codes and data are avaialble at Github and HuggingFace

More from ICML 2026

All ICML 2026 papers →