Position: AI Leaderboards Are Underserving the Global South: A Case Study from India
Abstract
This position paper argues that AI leaderboards are structurally ill-suited to serving the Global South because they lack independent governance, conflict-of-interest policies, and mechanisms for metric evolution. The barrier is not missing data. High-quality regional benchmarks already exist: IndicSUPERB, MILU, and LAHAJA for India; IrokoBench for Africa; AlGhafa for Arabic. The barrier is institutional design. Global leaderboards do not include these benchmarks, and no governance mechanism compels them to do so. Commercial pressure corrects leaderboard failures when paying customers in the Global North are affected. The Global South lacks equivalent leverage. Without governance, failures affecting Hindi, Swahili, or Arabic speakers persist indefinitely as documented but unaddressed gaps. Using India as a case study (1.4 billion people, 22 scheduled languages, high-quality benchmarks but no trusted aggregation), we report findings from a consultation with 82 AI practitioners showing strong preferences for formal, non-government governance and for disclosure-based conflict management. Our contribution is institutional, not technical: we argue that and why governance is the load-bearing solution, with India as the worked case.