Position: Bridge the AI development-regulation gap through dedicated committees and adaptive legislation
Abstract
While AI models advance at unprecedented rates, AI safety legislation in the United States remains largely stalled or unrealized. We observe that AI policy activity is increasing globally, yet binding enactments remain limited relative to the pace of technical capability releases. We argue that there is a need to actively bridge the AI development-regulation gap, and this requires dedicated AI committees, adaptable and preemptive legislation that is informed by comprehensive stakeholder input. We support our position through a technical analysis of all U.S. AI-related bills introduced from 2017 to 2025, showing that only 4.23% of U.S. AI bills reach any terminal outcome (6.25% for general bills). We identify a stage-specific pattern of legislative stalling: public-interest topics such as Deepfakes and Job Security predict initial committee engagement, while structural factors including the number of bill sponsors and chamber of origin predict late-stage advancement failure. Our comprehensive analysis of institutional, economic, political, and informational constraints shows factors exacerbating these regulatory delays. To address this multifaceted gap, we propose policy recommendations grounded in planned adaptation, preemptive enactment, and independent AI oversight. Finally, we highlight the need for coordinated action across policymakers, developers, and industry stakeholders so that AI safety governance keeps pace with technological innovation.