JADES: A Universal Framework for Jailbreak Assessment via Decompositional Scoring
Abstract
AbstractAccurately assessing jailbreak success remains unsolved, as existing automatic methods often diverge from human perception. To address this, we propose JADES, a universal evaluation framework that decomposes a harmful query into weighted sub-questions, scores each sub-answer, and aggregates the scores into a final decision; an optional fact-checking module further mitigates hallucination-induced misjudgments. We validate JADES on JailbreakQR, a meticulously annotated benchmark of 400 prompt–response pairs. Under binary settings (success/failure), JADES achieves 98.5% human agreement, outperforming strong baselines by over 9%. Re-evaluating five popular attacks across seven LLMs reveals systematic overestimation of jailbreak. JADES also enables granular ternary evaluation (failure/partial success/success), uncovers that partial successes dominate current reported successes, and recalibrates the perceived severity of existing attacks. Overall, JADES reveals a major limitation of current jailbreak evaluation and, together with ternary assessment, enables a more accurate understanding of the true jailbreak effectiveness.