Skip to content
conftrace_
2026 EMNLP EMNLP 2026

Debate-aware Learning Makes LLMs Genuine Debaters

AbstractMulti-agent debate systems are used to competitively discuss and resolve complex tasks. However, existing approaches often exhibit pseudo-debate behavior: agents either ignore opponents’ arguments or compromise too readily without critical evaluation. To address this, we propose a three-stage debate framework grounded in abstract argumentation theory. First, Debate Structuring uses principled prompts to elicit well-formed debate interactions. Second, Debate Imitation filters high-quality debates to fine-tune LLMs on proper argumentative conduct. Third, Debate Internalization employs a debate-aware reinforcement learning objective to instill adversarial reasoning patterns. To better quantify debate capability, we introduce two novel metrics: Rebuttal Engagement Score (RES), assessing how thoroughly models engage with opposing arguments, and Belief Governance Score (BGS), evaluating whether models appropriately retain or revise beliefs based on argument strength. Extensive evaluations across six benchmarks show that our framework not only improves task performance but also cultivates more authentic and robust debate behavior in LLMs. Our work contributes a theory-inspired training framework and evaluation suite for advancing multi-agent debate systems.

More from EMNLP 2026

All EMNLP 2026 papers →