How Instruction Hierarchy Breaks Under Pairwise Multi-Conflict Pressure
Abstract
AbstractAs large language models (LLMs) increasingly process instructions from multiple sources with different privilege ranks, preserving the priority of higher-rank directives over conflicting lower-rank ones is critical for safe and predictable deployment. However, existing evaluations mostly focus on limited conflict settings, leaving it unclear how models handle instruction hierarchy (IH) when multiple conflicts arise. To address this gap, we present the first systematic study of IH under multi-conflict settings and introduce MIH-Bench, a benchmark that scales the number of simultaneous conflicts across six pairwise hierarchy scenarios. Experiments on 21 LLMs show that IH compliance deteriorates sharply as conflicts accumulate, while neither model scale nor generation reliably predicts robustness. We further find that system-involving conflicts are the most vulnerable, a particularly concerning result given the safety-critical role of system prompts. Moreover, reasoning can improve conflict resolution, although the gains vary across models and are bounded by underlying model capability. These results show that current LLMs remain fragile in pairwise multi-conflict settings, highlighting the need for stronger hierarchy-aware alignment. Code and data are available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MIH-release-A5B8/