Beyond Paraphrases: Generalization Across Task Formats in Parametric Knowledge Editing
Abstract
AbstractKnowledge editing aims to update specific facts in language models to ensure reliable and up-to-date behavior. A key challenge is whether edited knowledge generalizes beyond the format in which the edit is applied, yet existing evaluations primarily assess generalization using paraphrases. In this work, we identify a critical blind spot: generalization across heterogeneous task formats, including multiple-choice and verification-based question answering. We show that paraphrase-based evaluations overestimate robustness, as models that perform well on paraphrases exhibit substantial performance drops across task formats. While model predictions are consistent across formats prior to editing, editing introduces format-dependent inconsistencies. We further observe that heterogeneous task formats exhibit distinct decision landscapes, where single-format objectives lead to format-specific local optima with divergent edit directions, resulting in misaligned outputs across formats. To address this issue, we demonstrate that aligning edit directions across task formats improves cross-format generalization and consistency. These findings highlight the need to move beyond paraphrase-based evaluation and to develop editing methods that maintain consistent factual behavior across diverse task formulations.