What Does BERT Know about Linguistic Features: Probing Finnish Model for Text Difficulty
Abstract
AbstractWe observe that fine-tuned BERT outperforms feature-based models at estimation of text difficulty, but it is unclear what drives this advantage. We explore a state-of-the-art Finnish BERT difficulty estimator and analyze it against a strong feature-based model trained on 66 hand-crafted linguistic features. First, we find that BERT implicitly encodes the coarse length and complexity features, but not fine-grained morphology of Finnish. Second, BERT subsumes the information in the hand-crafted features and adds signal that they miss: the two models are evenly matched on most documents, and BERT’s advantage comes from rarely being very wrong, rather than from winning everywhere. Third, through input perturbation and layer-wise probing, we show that BERT’s predictions rely on sentence-internal structure rather than on lexical content alone. Our analysis explains why a neural difficulty estimator succeeds and what linguistic information it depends on.