Skip to content
conftrace_
2026 EMNLP EMNLP 2026

PCP: A Controlled Benchmark for Pragmatic Intention Recognition in Clinical Communication

AbstractMedical LLMs are commonly evaluated on factual question answering, summarization, and explicitly stated clinical information, but less on pragmatic understanding: recovering intended meaning from indirectness, hedging, urgency cues, politeness, and implicature. We present PCP, a 3,533-item benchmark for pragmatic intention recognition in clinical communication, with a controlled synthetic Core split, a close-distractor Hard split, and a small externally grounded Real-Clean split derived from public doctor–patient dialogue datasets. PCP combines answer-choice artifact audits with blind human validation of all Hard and Real-Clean items plus a 300-item Core sample, and targeted expert review of 280 items. Across eleven systems (six API-accessed, five open-weight), our main finding is a recognition-vs-naming dissociation: ten of the eleven select the intended clinical action at 95.5–98.4% aggregate accuracy but name the pragmatic phenomenon licensing it at only 56.6–64.5%, a 32–40 pp gap on the same items. Recognition is also split-dependent: API-accessed models are near ceiling on PCP-Core (98.7–99.8%) but drop on PCP-Hard-469 (83.4–90.6%) and PCP-Real-Clean-64 (79.7–90.6%), so broad controlled probes can mask difficulty exposed by close distractors and externally grounded cases. Because gold actions are often the most medically defensible choice, accuracy is a confound-limited estimate; PCP is an evaluation resource for controlled clinical-pragmatic inference, not for deployment readiness.

🌉 Interdisciplinary Bridge - Artificial Intelligence and Natural Language Processing

More from EMNLP 2026

All EMNLP 2026 papers →