Beyond Binary ADHD Classification: Multimodal Phenotyping in a Clinical Psychiatric Cohort
Abstract
AbstractHigh-quality automated ADHD assessment has the potential to increase screening rates among individuals in clinical settings, but these methods are far from perfect. Binary classification methods can obscure differences among clinical populations, and computational ADHD studies often evaluate binary diagnostic prediction against neurotypical controls. Such comparisons can obscure which measurements remain useful when ADHD is distinguished from other psychiatric conditions. We address these gaps using the HYPERAKTIV clinical cohort and four measurements: the Conners Continuous Performance Test II (CPT-II), self-report questionnaires, heart-rate variability (HRV), and actigraphy. We examine three aspects of multimodal ADHD assessments: what information different modalities provide for binary ADHD classification, how well multimodal measurements distinguish the clinical groups, and how patterns in the features relate to clinical diagnosis in unsupervised analysis. CPT-II combined with self-report achieved the highest binary AUC (0.908), but was not reliably better than self-report alone under nested cross-validation. In the three-way task, the inattentive group was the hardest to identify. Clustering produced feature profiles that crossed diagnostic groups. These results suggest that adding more modalities does not necessarily improve classification and that feature-space structure does not always align with diagnostic groups.