The Enemy from Within: A Study of Political Delegitimization Discourse in Israeli Political Speech
Abstract
AbstractWe present the first large-scale computational study of political delegitimization discourse (PDD), defined as symbolic attacks on the normative validity of political entities. We curate and manually annotate a novel Hebrew-language corpus of 10,410 sentences drawn from parliamentary speeches (1993-2023), Facebook posts, and leading news outlets (2018-2021), of which 1,812 instances (17.4%) exhibit PDD and 642 carry additional annotations for intensity, incivility, target type, and affective framing. We introduce a two-stage classification pipeline, and benchmark finetuned encoder models and decoder LLMs. Our best model (DictaLM 2.0) attains an F1 of 0.74 for binary PDD detection and a macro-F1 of 0.67 for classification of delegitimization characteristics. Applying this classifier to longitudinal and cross-platform data, we see a marked rise in PDD over three decades, higher prevalence on social media versus parliamentary debate, greater use by male politicians than by their female counterparts, and stronger tendencies among right-leaning actors, with pronounced spikes during election campaigns and major political events. Our findings demonstrate the feasibility and value of automated PDD analysis for analyzing democratic discourse.